Wilmington Underground
heart and soul of our Wilmington community
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Wilmington Yard Sales! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com

I have a question that I need opinions on

who's talking here?

oceanbreeze 4
Nani 1
Embrace Change 1
expo_mama 2
Princess Crankypants*leave my 4
LoveMyLab 1
~YFF~ 3
poosh 1
Aunt Ruby 1
beachy living :) 1
Ilovealldogs 1
4 my 3 girls 6

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

4 my 3 girls --- 19 years ago -

Over a month ago, it was near the middle of Feb. or the first of Feb. (somewhere around in there) I received some clothes for free from the freecycle site. I could wear the clothes at first, but at the beginning of March, I left my husband and now I am having financial problems (some of you may remember me posting about needing household items and furniture). I will not go into details but it's pretty bad. I didn't just decide I don't want to be married anymore either. There was abuse involved. Anyway, I had some clothes that I got for free on the freecycle website and I have gained about 20 pounds this last month just with all the stress and everything I have been through. Well, I listed them on WYS and I got an email today from the lady who gave them to me. She was very rude and told me she didn't give them away so that I could profit from them. I did email her and explain that I didn't INTENTIONALLY get the clothes to re-sell. I just have gained weight, need some financial help and decided to list them. Now, my question, was that wrong of me? She has really made me feel like I have done something really bad. I told her that for the items that I have already sold, which I think was only 2-3, I would donate the money to charity or send it back to her. I also told her I would take all the other clothes off and donate them since she was so upset about it. I have taken them all off (I think I got them all!) and will send them to the Salvation army or vintage values. I am just curious to see if maybe I should not have sold them or if others think there was nothing wrong with it. I mean I can see if I intentionally got them to re-sell. I even had a post on WYS that I have gained weight and I need clothes. I took it down because I am meeting several people to look at the clothes they have. Tell me what you think? Please be honest, you won't hurt my feelings. 

Ilovealldogs --- 19 years ago -

It's too bad people can be so judgmental without knowing someone or understanding his/her situation. When you get something from someone, whether you pay or not, it becomes yours and you can choose to do with it as you so please and that includes selling it at a higher profit. Now, I would not suggest purposely doing that on this site, but after reading your situation, it is understandable although I think it was a good idea to donate the clothes since they were free to you. Either way, it is not the seller's business what you do with his/her former items. 

oceanbreeze --- 19 years ago -

wow..sounds like you are having a bad day to..what is going on with everyone being so rude to one another..I am sorry to hear that someone was mean to you...I say they are your clothes now ..do what you want with them..I mean YOU are the seller now..not them right?? geez..what in the world?? why all the rudeness right? 

poosh --- 19 years ago -

When I give stuff or clothes away it becomes theirs to do with what they wish.If they manage to sell it then hey I'm happy for them.Did it ever occur to this person that even though you got them for free you can no longer wear them and you might need the money from the sale of them to purchase some that you can wear?Lord,can't have you running round butt naked just to pacify someone else. 

Nani --- 19 years ago -

i could see the lady's POV I do think that you should've emailed her first and let her know what your intentions and your situation were, so that she wouldnt mind so much. I've been on the other side and i do have to say, when i give something away, i do it with the best intentions and making sure whoever gets my stuff can actually benefit from them, specially if you have a high number of people wanting the same thing. I always say, please do not resale, give it away or email me and i'll take back so it can be forwarded to someone else in need. but if i see the stuff i gave away for sale, it makes me feel that i was taken advantage of. 

~YFF~ --- 19 years ago -

I can kinda see this from both sides, in this situation the lady was inappropiate in how she handled this. I am sorry she was rude to you. I hope your situation gets a lot better sooner than you expect! Much love But on the other hand, that man settin up the blue boxes... I would be pissed if I gave my clothes to a charity and to see someone selling what I know is my old clothes on wys. But those are two different situations. 

4 my 3 girls --- 19 years ago -

Thanks everyone for your honest opinions. I did not have her email address still, since it had been so long since we had any contact. So emailing her or contacting her about the clothes was not an option. I guess I can just say lesson learned. I either won't get any more clothes from people off freecycle or if I do, I will not sell them. I really did not have intentions on re-selling those clothes when I got them. 

oceanbreeze --- 19 years ago -

its ok 4my3girls..I had to vent on here to earlier today about someone being"rude" to me..and I don't usually vent to often..but it feels good now that I did and I got some support..hope you feel better soon to! 

4 my 3 girls --- 19 years ago -

Thanks bb girl still. I have had a really bad day today and I get home and this is the first email I read. I hope your day is going better! 

oceanbreeze --- 19 years ago -

yes I was sooo depressed earlier..but I have so many friends on wu(except for the one that "hurt" my feelings..but that is ok-she may come on apologize later?) -all my "friends" have shown me love and support and it has made all the difference. **I truly do hope you feel better soon!** 

4 my 3 girls --- 19 years ago -

Thank you! You are too sweet. You have made me feel a lot better. I just emailed a lady who I was going to sell one of the items to and told her I could no longer sell the item and that I was sorry for any inconvenience. I hope she understands. Have a great night! 

Aunt Ruby --- 19 years ago -

My two cents worth: If I sell it to you or give it to you - it's yours, why should I care what you do with it. We're talking about items, not living creatures Make a dollor or two off of it if you can.........at least it's out of my house and one less thing I have to dust, clean, store, or more from room to room. 

Princess Crankypants*leave my --- 19 years ago -

I am no expert on anything other than silly songs...see my other posts.. I can see both sides so I will present them...these lessons were recently learned from a post I made earlier regarding a similar situation..... Your view-------the giver does not know your situation. You are not making a killing off of the clothing and you are in a bind right now. Her view-------she gave willingly to someone who presented with a need. It hurts her feelings because of the giving. She does have a right to an opinion and did not post here but handled it privately... In closing I will say...if you feel badly about it, it may not have been the best idea.... IF it does not bother you then groove on :) BTW: Check out another silly one post!! actually I meant to check out I'm on a roll post...but either one will work!!! 

expo_mama --- 19 years ago -

I see both point of views. When i give someone something I dont want u to profit from it, or else I would of given it away, thats just me. True its yours now to do as u wish, but..... as someone said a simple, I dont need the clothes anymore, can i sell them or give them away would do! I understand your situation throughly and I wish u luck. And had it been me who gave them to u, I wouldnt of been mean, but I would of prob said just give them to someone u think can benefit from them. Just my point of view and my feelings on it! (dont shoot me:( ) 

~YFF~ --- 19 years ago -

I love your post dippy ( I can't remember who you(originally) are sorry) 

Princess Crankypants*leave my --- 19 years ago -

just a humble person trying to lighten the mood....I have joined in infrequently...got my feelings hurt on a post awhile back... Recently changed my name to protect those that are obviously more intelligent than I am.... nothing but peace, love and happiness here! Peace Love Happiness 

Princess Crankypants*leave my --- 19 years ago -

oops try again------see what I mean-----just lack that intelligence gene that is all-------Photo Sharing and Video Hosting at Photobucket>Peace love Happiness 

expo_mama --- 19 years ago -

seems to be a lot of feelings hurt here lately! But u know its hard, we all have opinions! cant we all just get along? LOL 

beachy living :) --- 19 years ago -

I would probably be upset if I gave you something and you sold it just because. BUT, with your circumstances, I see nothing wrong. I would have done the same. Why have a bunch of clothes that you can't wear, especially if you need the $$. 

Princess Crankypants*leave my --- 19 years ago -

seems to be a lot of feelings hurt here lately! But u know its hard, we all have opinions! I am way over it..... Learned a lot and moved on------- 

LoveMyLab --- 19 years ago -

Thank you everyone for your postings...I am "the rude lady"...I had originally planned to post the situation here myself to get some point of views but figured I would just do it privately. It did hurt my feelings to see items that I had given away being sold for a profit. I did not think about the person's situation and appreciate you explaining '4 my 3 girls'...it does make me feel better. I apologize for not approaching you maybe nicer?...I didn't think it was that rude seeing as how I think that most people would be at least a bit shocked to see multiple items being sold after giving them away. I am sorry to hear about your situation and hope that things look up. I do agree that once items are given/bought they are the new owner's to do as they please...however, I don't believe that it is in good conscience to sell items that you received for free when the person that gave them to you was under the impression that you could use the items for your own good (or figured you would give them away to the next person if they didn't fit, etc.). In your case, I now know you didn't do this intentionally...whether you could wear the clothes or sell them, they have helped you out and that is always my hope when freecycling. There are people who make a hobby/living outta getting free stuff and selling them or buying and selling at a higher price. This was my first thought when seeing my items on WYS. Again, I am sorry for making you feel bad or coming off as rude. I will try to ask questions in the future before assuming the worst and I hope that you will consider passing items that you receive from freecycle to other freecyclers when you don't have a need for them any longer. 

oceanbreeze --- 19 years ago -

"nice' apology letter(you didn't scream at her at all in all "caps" either- that is what an apology letter is all about"an apology" that you are sorry-that was so nice of you lovemylab)-that was very sweet of you to let her know you are sorry for being mean and rude..hope you two become friends! 

4 my 3 girls --- 19 years ago -

Thank you 'Love my Lab', that really means a lot to me. I am glad that you do understand that I didn't do that intentionally and that I very rarely get things from freecycle. I actually have not gotten anything from anyone since getting the clothes from you. I have pulled all the items off (if you see any more, please let me know) and I will be taking them to Vintage Values today. I had a very bad day yesterday and maybe your email upset me more than it normally would have. I do hope you know that I understand where you are coming from and you are so right when you say there are lots of people who go to freecycle to get stuff to re-sell. I personally do not feel that is right. If anyone here does that, I'm not judging you, this is just my personal opinion. I do not have any hard feelings and I can say this was a lesson learned. I will be sure that if I ever get anything for free (from anyone, not just freecycle) I will be sure to give it away to another person or to charity. Thanks again! 

Embrace Change --- 19 years ago -

I'm glad things worked out! :-) I agree with beach living. "Why have a bunch of clothes that you can't wear, especially if you need the $$." If you will have a yard sale, let me know. I have some clothings and things I want to get rid off that you can sell. And if those help you out in your situation, I'll be the happiest! 

~YFF~ --- 19 years ago -

I am so glad this worked out so nicely!  

4 my 3 girls --- 19 years ago -

Thanks Daena. I will probably end up giving all of my items to charity. I have been thinking about doing that anyway. I have a whole room full of things and I just don't have the time to take pics, then post and keep up with the emails that I get for the items. My days are usually pretty full and things just don't sell fast unless it is a rare item. I keep saying I am just going to have a yard sale, and then whatever is left goes to charity. I just haven't had the time to do that yet either (can you tell that working 50-60 hours a week and raising 3 kids takes up a lot of my time :-)). Being a seller on WYS is really almost a full time job in itself. Before my husband and I split I bought a 3 month membership to WYS, that ends in a couple of weeks (sometime in May) and I more than likely will not renew. None of what happened has anything to do with my decision. It is just something I have been thinking about for a while. I moved into this house and everything that I didn't want anymore went into what is supposed to be my dining room. And the pile keeps growing as I continue to still unpack. Hope you are having a great day! 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

advice
wys

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy

Wilmington Underground