Wilmington Underground
heart and soul of our Wilmington community
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Wilmington Yard Sales! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com

more advice needed on what to tell daughter :o(

who's talking here?

Serendipity 2
Princess Crankypants*leave my 1
Aunt Ruby 5
♥ skyler ♥ 2
CommunicationIsKey 1
Tiffany 12
billie 5
sc girl 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

Tiffany --- 17 years ago -

ok, so, Geneva got a hermit crab this summer and LOVES it. she still likes it but doesn;t really play with it as much anymore. Well, he won't change shells. He kept switching shells but always went back to the old one. Now..he is out all together and we KNOW he is dieing. WHAT DO I TELL HER!!! Last January, we lost my cat of 18 years and I told her that Chelsy had not been felling good and that she needed to go to a new home to someone that would make her feel better, so she went to be with Jesus. I can;t do the same thing for the crab. I don;t want her to start thinking that Jesus is taking her animals. She is only 3 but VERY smart for her age!! I thought about telling her he got out his cage and ran away!! I am at a loss!! HELP ME!!  

Aunt Ruby --- 17 years ago -

I thought about telling her he got out his cage and ran away!! Then she may think he ran away because he didn't like her - those little brains can go in so many directions. You've got a difficult issue to deal with - Can you tell her that he is sick and has to go to the "hermit crab doctor", then allow some days to go by and handle it from there. Gee, I don't know! Good luck to you on this one. 

billie --- 17 years ago -

I think telling her the truth is the best way to handle it. Even little kids are able to understand more than you think they can. She'll actually work it out in her own way. It is a way to begin to teach her that death is a part of life. You might even let her do a little funeral for her pet. 

Tiffany --- 17 years ago -

DANG!! you have a point! UGH!! I seriously thought about telling he he died. For some unknown reason, she knows the word, SEEMS to know a bit of the meaning. Now I know that she has NO iead what it REALLY menas, but... UGH!!! I know this crab is going to be dead tomorrow, I just KNOW IT!! The claw has fallen off!! it is still alive and moving and at 1st, we thought it was just molting. (sheding) but....now, we know it's not. :o( 

Tiffany --- 17 years ago -

I think telling her the truth is the best way to handle it. Even little kids are able to understand more than you think they can. She'll actually work it out in her own way. It is a way to begin to teach her that death is a part of life. You might even let her do a little funeral for her pet. I thought about that too. I am SO confused right now. I HATE those big blue eyes looking up at me in sadness!!!! 

billie --- 17 years ago -

I thought about that too. I am SO confused right now. I HATE those big blue eyes looking up at me in sadness!!!! You'll hate it worse if she ever ask you why you lied to her. Children are taught to be truthful by being told the truth. You do not have to be overly graphic, but honesty is the best policy. Always. 

♥ skyler ♥ --- 17 years ago -

I agree 

Aunt Ruby --- 17 years ago -

If you hate those big blue eyes looing up at you in sadness, then she has herself a good mama!!! You'll do fine. I'll add you to my prayer list tonight. 

Tiffany --- 17 years ago -

DAng it Billie!! Why are you right!!! I think that is just what I am gonna do. better yet, I'll make you come do it. It's not like you can't find my house! lol lol 

Tiffany --- 17 years ago -

Thanks ya'll. It is just making it hard cause I keep thinking about Chelsy so I am a little more emotional about it. This is our 1st Christmas in 18 years with her so....I'm toucy on it now. Thanks Auntie...thanks Snook. I really appreciate it. Billie, I will thank you in person when you come tell her. 

CommunicationIsKey --- 17 years ago -

I've read that child development experts think that having pets in the home are good on many levels and that one of the reasons is so that they can come to understand (and accept) that all creatures will eventually come to the ends of their lives. Children must experience it...grief is normal. Tell her the truth. Then wish the hermit crab everlasting peace by having a pet funeral. 

Princess Crankypants*leave my --- 17 years ago -

Also, if you tell her it got sick and then went to Jesus...she is going to think that everytime she or someone else gets sick they are going away 2 Jesus... Ran into that one not too long ago when my then 4 year old wanted to go to Heaven to see her granpa 

Tiffany --- 17 years ago -

will ya'll stop being right! lol I RALLY appreciat you all for helping me out. We are gonna tell her the truth. 

Aunt Ruby --- 17 years ago -

hard cause I keep thinking about Chelsy so I am a little more emotional about it. This is our 1st Christmas in 18 years with her so....I'm toucy on it now. Sounds like a good time to get a new kitty!! Lots of pain when our Sheena died, but Nudge has worked his way right into our hearts and the house 'feels right' again. 

Tiffany --- 17 years ago -

Also, if you tell her it got sick and then went to Jesus...she is going to think that everytime she or someone else gets sick they are going away 2 Jesus... TOTALLY thought the same thing. See, this may sound wrong, but Chelsy was special and i in NO way can compare this crab to my kitty, but I have to do what is best for her, and the truth is best. I just have to figure out how to word it. But....I am NORMALLY goods with words, so it'll come to me. OH WAIT!!!! I am making Billie do it!! lol lol 

Aunt Ruby --- 17 years ago -

OH WAIT!!!! I am making Billie do it!! Wrap up billie, it's cold out!!!!!! 

Tiffany --- 17 years ago -

Sounds like a good time to get a new kitty!! WE have a cat in our home that my husband and I got 2 weeks after we got married so we have had him for 8 years. My mom and Dad would NOT let me take MY Chelsy with me!! DANG THEM! ha ha ha But...you know after I go married, Chelsy would not "talk" to me for a year!!!! She would come up in sit in my hubby's lap and look at me like..."in yer face! " Ask my mom, she STILL talks about it!! That cat even woke my dad up on night to "alert" him that someone was breaking in his shed!! HOW COOL WAS SHE!! lol Geneva asks us all the time if we miss her and she says she wants her to come home. But...she's not as upset about her being gone now. 

Aunt Ruby --- 17 years ago -

sit in my hubby's lap and look at me like..."in yer face! " That's funny - JUST like a cat!!! I'm off to la-la land now. Good luck in the morning. You'll do just fine! 

♥ skyler ♥ --- 17 years ago -

goodnite :) 

Tiffany --- 17 years ago -

thanks auntie. I'm going to do it. Should make hubby do it....but....that's me. I'll let ya'll know how it goes :o( Thanks agian and good night to all you sleepy heads. 

billie --- 17 years ago -

DAng it Billie!! Why are you right!!! I think that is just what I am gonna do. better yet, I'll make you come do it. It's not like you can't find my house! lol lol It's possible I may be in the neighborhood soon. Maybe I can meet your daughter. 

Tiffany --- 17 years ago -

You coming to see Sandra and the bunch!! if so, let me know when you are coming and I will walk down!!! 

billie --- 17 years ago -

You coming to see Sandra and the bunch!! if so, let me know when you are coming and I will walk down!!! Possibly tomorrow if she is home. I haven't reached her by phone over the weekend. I suppose she may have gone to Claudia's. I'll let you know. You can bring me that new juicer you're selling. Deal? 

Tiffany --- 17 years ago -

you want it? it is my "sis' I don;t even knwo what she has it listed for. 

billie --- 17 years ago -

I do. I'll go order it properly on WYS. I'm going to bed. Goodnight. 

Tiffany --- 17 years ago -

Don;t do that silly!! I saw it...5.00. I'll ppu it for you. If you don;t get by, just let me know. SINCE it is you....I'll make arrangements for ya. :o) 

Serendipity --- 17 years ago -

I agree with a lot of what has been said already! Tell her the truth...have a funeral for the crab. One of our cats ran away a month or so ago. He wasn't the type of cat to just run away...so something had to have happened to him. My daughter immediately started praying for the cat and understands a bit about death and heaven. She told me she thought that maybe he is in heaven now after a week or so went by. She amazed me praying on her own about the cat. She is 4. It's hard, but kids do understand so much more than we think they do sometimes. Good luck hun! 

sc girl --- 17 years ago -

omg..I used to have a hermit crab..LOL 

Serendipity --- 17 years ago -

My Mom has told me in the past that when I was younger that I wanted to have a funeral for everything. If one of our fish died, I had a funeral for it. Bird, neighborhood cat, you name it. Kind of morbid, but I guess it's not when it's a little kid just being sweet. 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy

Wilmington Underground